Sucker for Love: Crush Landing Review - Dating an alien has never been this tense

I had no idea what to expect from this game when I got it. As we all know I don’t do horror, but I also never really played any dating sims, not because I don’t like them, but because I never had a chance to try any. Honestly, they seemed kind of boring and I'd rather sink my time in an adventure where I get to slice and dice with my sword and, at the very least, shoot some bad guys.

So I stepped into the Sucker for Love universe and came across cosmic dread, paranoia, comedy, and romance all crammed into one small apartment, and somehow…It all works fine together? I knew I wasn’t going to get a straight horror experience, and I was right about that (thank god). Instead, I got something genuinely charming, occasionally funny, and just enough unsettling in a way that snuck up on me more than once.

Don’t let the lack of proper jumpscares drive you away from Crush Landing, as the paranoia and dread that it delivers is very much worth it.

Love at first light

Sucker for Love: Crush Landing is the fourth entry in the Sucker for Love franchise, which comes after Prelude, First Date, and Date to Die For, and it is my first real introduction to the series. Each game combines the dating sim charm with cosmic horror in its own way, and as I went in without any previous experience with these games, I can say that Crush Landing serves as a well enough starting point. I never felt lost or like I was missing any context.

Crush Landing starts simple enough. You’re the protagonist (later on given the name Dude, as we don’t know the actual name), who is returning home after a date, and just as you arrive in front of your building, you see that you’ve got a guest, and an unexpected one.

AltChar

The main objective in Crush Landing seems easier than it really is.

A glowing meteorite crashed right into your apartment, and is just chilling in the middle of the room instead of destroying everything around it, the way you’d expect. Rather than panic, a quick call to a friend reveals a much more practical angle, as a meteorite that lands on your property is legally yours. In translation - money. All you have to do is keep it burning until museum representatives arrive to collect it, with your name proudly displayed next to it once it gets to the museum. 

Before any of that happens, you get an introduction to Hheily, the entity that arrived with the meteorite. She (or it?) is a shapeshifting presence who takes the form of a beautiful girl, which you pulled out of a magazine that was sitting on your bed. She’s confused about her situation, doesn’t really communicate in a way that you understand, and yet somehow manages to be genuinely charming despite it all. From here, your task shifts entirely to keeping Hheily well and still alive, and you do that by feeding her specific things she needs to stay stable. 

AltChar

Sucker for Love: Crush Landing excels in its art-style as well as humour.

What makes the story compelling is how quickly it stops feeling purely charming. As long as you’re interacting with Hheily, whether it's feeding her certain colours or simply interacting with her, everything feels okay, manageable, and even sweet. But the moment you turn away from her, and focus on the rest of the world around you, that sense of ease disappears. 

You’re never quite sure who’s your friend, who is on the other side of the door, or who is calling the phone. When you open that door, is on the other side someone who is being truthful or someone who is not telling you everything? These are the questions that the game throws at you, but never rushes to answer them.

Colours, consequences, and creeping dread

At its core, the game revolves around one task: keeping Hheily  alive and glowing by feeding her specific colours she needs to stay stable. It sounds rather simple, right? Well, on paper it does, yes, but the game asks you to actually think rather than just toss random objects into the meteorite.

Every item you feed might lock that specific colour out for future use, meaning you can’t repeat a solution once you’ve used it, which forces you to keep exploring your surroundings and looking for new options as you play. Some of the items that produce a certain colour might not be as obvious as others, so you need to think things through carefully.

AltChar

Interacting with Hheily always leads to an interesting, but also charming time.

The exploration mostly happens through interacting with objects around your apartment. You'll be inspecting, collecting, and occasionally combining or altering items. Those items aren’t static either and they can change over time, such as ripe bananas becoming overripe over time, and cooking or boiling something will change its properties. It’s important to keep timing and awareness on your mind, as the world shifts around you. There is an in-game timer as well, though you’ll be able to fast-forward it if you’re waiting on something specific to happen.

You can also leave your apartment, but the bulk of the tension happens inside your four walls, and from what arrives at your door rather than where you go yourself. Phone calls and visitors interrupt your routine constantly, some harmless and some probably not, and figuring out which one is which is an important part of the gameplay loop, layered on top of the colour-feeding mechanic. Once you’ve given Hheily every colour, you’re rewarded with a heart which moves the story along.

AltChar

While there are not many interactions outside the apartment, the ones that are available are worth exploring.

Multiple endings are available depending on the choices you make and items you use during your playthrough, meaning a solution that worked once, might not work the same way on the second run.

That replayability expands even further, whether you’re chasing achievements or simply curiosity of what might happen. I did hit an ending early on without even trying to, and then I managed to loop back into the same result a few times until I figured out some things. Some mechanics click easier, and some take time, but that doesn’t take away from the charm of the game.

Beautiful, but also unsettling

If there’s one thing that Crush Landing gets right, it’s the visuals. The art style and animation immediately called to mind old-school anime, both in the characters and in the environments that surround them, and it’s genuinely hard to find a single weak spot across the entire presentation.

That level of polish isn’t necessarily what you’d  expect from something carrying a “cosmic horror” tag, but it works nonetheless.

AltChar

As the story moves forward, you'll get to see things turn weirder and more bizarre.

The voice acting is very well done, and matches the same quality. It’s done with care, adding weight to Hheily’s confusion and charm in a way text alone wouldn't quite capture. You can tell when there is excitement, when there is confusion, and annoyance as well.

The soundtrack deserves just as much credit, though for a different reason. It’s chill and mellow for most of the experience, fitting a “this could be the end of the world, but at least the vibe is nice” tone perfectly. What’s more impressive, though, is how the music and sound design shift the moment tension creeps in, subtly amplifying that sense of paranoia every time the phone rings or someone’s at the door. It’s a genuinely effective contrast, colourful, cosmic charm on one side, and a soundscape of impending doom on the other.

AltChar

The art-style of Crush Landing will remind you of old-school animes and Japanese animated movies.

I didn’t encounter any significant performance issues while playing, besides the game sometimes lagging when I was opening and closing the door, and some minor lag here and there, but nothing too severe to actually get in the way of the experience.

Charming, chaotic, and worth another playthrough

I'll admit, horror isn't usually my genre, but Crush Landing made a genuinely convincing case for itself. It manages something that sounds like it shouldn't work on paper, balancing colourful, comedic charm with a real undercurrent of paranoia, and somehow never lets either side undercut the other.

One moment you're chatting with a shapeshifting cosmic entity shaped like a magazine cutout, the next you're staring at your front door wondering if you should even answer it. That is something I've never experienced in my games previously, and if nothing else sounds compelling to you, then you should at least give it a try because of that. It's truly an interesting thing to see horror conveyed through something that doesn't contain gore or jumpscares.

As someone completely new to the Sucker for Love franchise, Crush Landing left a strong first impression, strong enough that I'd happily go back and play through Prelude, First Date, and Date to Die For as well. If the rest of the series brings the same mix of charm, tension, and genuine unpredictability, I'm in.