Pixelshire Review - Pretty Pixels Can't Hide the Bugs

There’s been no shortage of quality AAA games in the past few years, yet one of my all-time favourites up until this day still comes from a tiny indie team, a gem that’s Ghost of a Tale. One has to give credit where credit's due, which unfortunately hasn’t quite been the case with my experience of Pixelshire.

First announced on June 7, 2022, Pixelshire is a 2D top-down farm life sim with town-building, terraforming, exploration, and light combat mechanics. Settings aside the obvious many will jump to, which is the overall look and feel of the game, Stardew Valley (itself inspired by Harvest Moon) and Pixelshire have a bit more in common, as Pixelshire is also the work of a solo developer. But a solo-dev story only stretches so far.

Online reactions leading up to the release, mainly referring to the comments under IGN’s recent Pixelshire video, point to a kind of cultural gatekeeping that does more harm than good. While I do acknowledge the comparison, I'd rather steer clear of that discussion - no single game needs to keep a chokehold on the whole genre. 

AltChar

Pixelshire

Now with all of that out of the way, time to face the music.

I wanted to like Pixelshire, but it didn’t exactly sweep me off my feet. It’s chill and cosy, no doubt, and there’s a strong appetite for that right now, but after 15 hours of play, what started as a lukewarm first impression turned into a slow, bland grind riddled with bugs.

The review embargo lifted yesterday, but I chose to give it a bit more time and the benefit of the doubt. It’s a slow-burn game, after all, but one that feels more undercooked, and it never quite captured me the way I hoped it would.

AltChar

Pixelshire

Story and gameplay

Pixelshire is visually a charming game, but for these kinds of games to be more than just another entry, the story better be good to keep its players invested. This is where it fell short for me.

You begin with a familiar narrative setup: your homeland was ravaged by war, greed drove its people away, and you set sail in search of a better life only to suffer a shipwreck and wash ashore in Pixelshire with no previous memory of who you are.

You’ll meet characters along the way: Captain Farell, a pirate-turned-fisherman; Eva, the town’s mayor; Valerie, a warrior, to name a few. Others join your settlement as it grows, like Iowa the farmer, or Nobeko the archaeologist. Relationship-building and romance options are included, and characters can accompany you on quests or tasks.

AltChar

Pixelshire

Overall it’s not a bad premise, but the characters are disappointingly thin and transactional, feeling more like quest dispensers rather than people you want to learn more about. For a game built around community, that’s a big miss. The overall story feels a bit too safe - not such a problem in itself, but it lacks the depth that might make you care.

The gameplay is pretty standard. Movement is WASD, interacting is done with E, inventory is mapped to B. Equipping and using items involves a combination of right-clicking to equip items to your tool menu and using quick-access Q to use it.

Progression is structured around blueprints and XP earned through tasks, with talents spread across farming, woodworking, mining, cooking, fishing, brewing, magic, and combat. At its core, this is a farm life sim with emphasis on town customisation, but by the time I unlocked the ability to meaningfully customise my town, I already felt burnt out.

AltChar

Pixelshire

Terraforming, Pixelshire’s supposed big differentiator, could have brought more. You can raise land by one level and dig down by two, mainly to make room for fields or water. It’s a mechanic with huge potential, but right now feels half-formed.

Bugs and UI

A bit of digging reveals that Pixelshire has been in development since 2020, if not earlier even, yet beneath its charming surface is a foundation that simply isn’t stable. The UI still needs massive work, and while I don’t mind an occasional bug here and there, the volume here is hard to ignore.

AltChar

Pixelshire

One of the first why are you like this moments happened while selling items to an NPC, and it remained so throughout the game. After confirming the item sale, the count for that item in my shop inventory would drop to zero, but the item itself wouldn't disappear until I manually switched tabs to get the inventory to refresh and remove the now non-existent item. More frustrating was the inability to deselect a single item, forcing me to cancel the sale and start again if I misclicked.

Then there's the Talents tab. Every time I opened it, a random talent perk bubble would pop up on screen even if I hadn’t clicked anything. And then there’s the utterly useless fences. What’s the point of them if my chickens, cows, and NPCs will just walk through them?

AltChar

Pixelshire

Aside from the occasional inability of the game to predict player choices, my biggest issue was repairing tools at the blacksmith. There’s a slot where you’re meant to select an item to repair, but... it simply doesn’t work.

Tool upgrades are buggy too. A single wooden sword can somehow be used multiple times to craft copper versions, but upgrading a copper sword to an iron one does what it’s supposed to do - you end up with only one iron sword in your inventory as the lower-tier sword has been consumed for an upgrade. Then when you equip those upgraded items to your tool menu, the icons remain the same so you’ll have no idea what you’re actually holding until you unequip it.

There's also a bunch of other smaller bugs that add up over time. It’s a mess. And not the kind of charming mess you forgive in an Early Access title. This is a full release.

AltChar

Pixelshire

Final thoughts

There’s nothing easy about writing a negative review. On one hand, I have no doubt that real passion, time, and effort went into making Pixelshire, but it’s equally true that a full-price release needs to deliver a level of polish that simply isn’t present here.

If there’s something special hidden deep in Pixelshire, I didn’t find it in my first 15 hours, and I can’t see myself going back for more. Maybe it needed more time, or maybe it should’ve launched in Early Access. As it stands, it’s a game that promised something different and unique but under-delivered.